Musings of a crunchy, domestic goddess

Just another mama musing about her kids, Attachment Parenting, activism, photography, and life in general

Super? Nanny March 13, 2007

Filed under: Activism,Attachment Parenting,Breastfeeding,Kids,Parenting — amygeekgrl @ 7:00 pm

Mamas all over the Internet are voicing their opinion on the latest episode of ABC’s “SuperNanny” today. Some think Jo’s advice to the family was completely uneducated and out of line, others have issues with parts of it and still others think there was nothing wrong with it at all. Of course I have my own thoughts on the matter to share and, now that I have a minute to get on the computer, I will do just that.

First of all, this family had a LOT of issues, namely needing to set boundaries, find some balance in their family life, and find an alternative to “whoopin'” the kids (which is what the mom called the spankings her kids received). Although the mom held her14-month-old baby a lot, nursed her on demand and the parents co-slept with their 6-year-old as well as the baby, this family was not practicing Attachment Parenting nor seemed to have any desire to.

The mom seemed reluctant to wean the baby at first, but then changed her mind and said she was ready. I applaud her for breastfeeding for as long as she did, considering only 17.2% of moms in the U.S. were still nursing their children at 12 months old (in 2003) per the CDC, even though the AAP recommends “Exclusive breastfeeding for approximately the first six months and support for breastfeeding for the first year and beyond as long as mutually desired by mother and child.”

The fact that the mom decided to wean does not bother me, however, the way Jo handled the weaning process (cold-turkey) seemed pretty darn awful. There are much gentler ways of getting a baby to wean than to go cold-turkey. Plus, it’s not good for the mom to just up and quit like that. I’m sure her boobs were about ready to explode and I hope she didn’t develop mastitis (breast infection) as a result. I wish they would’ve consulted a lactation consultant or two before giving out advice on weaning. Perhaps if they had, they would’ve known better than to encourage the mom to give her 14-month-old a bottle. Bottle use past 12 months of age is discouraged because it can lead to mouth/teeth problems.

From “Stopping breastfeeding abruptly, or “cold turkey,” can be very distressing for both mother and baby and can cause plugged ducts, breast infection, or even a breast abscess. Hormone levels are also more likely to take a drastic plunge, causing mood swings, depression, etc. It’s very rare that sudden weaning is truly necessary. If someone suggests to you that this is required, get a second opinion. It would also be helpful to talk to a lactation consultant and/or a La Leche League Leader, who will be able to suggest alternatives and, if necessary, help you to wean with as little distress to mom and baby as possible.” Kellymom also has recommendations for gradual or partial weaning.

I felt many of the comments Jo made about breastfeeding or about the mom keeping the baby close to her were made with disdain. Rather than supporting the mom for breastfeeding her child, Jo seemed to be appalled that the nursing relationship continued. Perhaps she needs reminding of the AAP’s recommendation (12 months+) or WHO’s recommendations (2 years+) regarding breastfeeding.

I also disagreed with the way they transitioned the baby from co-sleeping with mom and dad to sleeping in a crib using CIO (cry it out). I felt that it was unusually cruel to first take her off the breast cold-turkey, then make her CIO in a crib (even if it was only for 5 minutes) when she’d been so accustomed to the closeness and security of mom for the past 14 months. Again, gentler methods could have been used.

More from “When you’re actively weaning, be sure to offer lots of cuddling and extra affection during the day. As your child grows older, nursing becomes much more than a way to satisfy hunger and thirst. It provides him with much comfort, security and closeness, so be as sensitive to his needs as you possibly can be throughout the process.”

They sure missed the mark on that one. Also, the way Jo applauded the mom for remaining “detached” while she listened to her baby CIO behind a closed door made me feel sick to my stomach. 😦 No parent should ever be praised for their detachment from their children, especially while the child cries alone.

I felt really sorry for the baby (the only one in the family who couldn’t voice her feelings) in all of this. I agree that the mom needed to pay more attention to her other children (and stop hitting them!), but there are better ways of handling it all. Perhaps Jo could’ve offered her a sling and showed her how to wear her baby (which would allow her to get more things done and still satisfy the baby’s needs) rather than just tell her to break off her attachment with her.

I know numerous families with more than one child who don’t have to break the attachment with one child to spend time with the other(s). It might take more work and ingenuity to figure out a balance, but nobody said parenting would be easy.

Another thing that bothered me was Jo saying that the baby was missing developmental milestones because she was so attached. Hmmm. I’ve never heard of a baby missing milestones from being worn/held or breastfed, the opposite is often true – the babies thrive because their needs are being met.

Overall, I’m grateful that the “SuperNanny” helped mom to realize that hitting her kids is not an effective or good discipline tactic and I hope that the family was able to find some balance after all of this. Those older two kids (not the nephew) really seemed to be crying out for attention and hopefully they are getting more now. I just wish the baby’s needs were considered a bit more. After all, she’s part of the family too.

If you wish to voice your opinion on this episode to ABC, click here or email Nick Powell, the creator and executive producer of both the American and British versions of the show – Craig Armstrong and Nick Emmerson are executive producers of the American version. Supernanny is produced by Ricochet, Ltd.


7 Responses to “Super? Nanny”

  1. Heather Says:

    that is why I don’t watch that show. I don’t like alot of Super Nanny’s techniques. I agree – her methods get immediate results & have the kids behave but I don’t think the methods are best for long term. I do agree with getting down on childs level & being somewhat organized. But don’t agree with the naughty mat or her approach to sleep, etc.

  2. amygeekgrl Says:

    heather – i hear ya. i don’t generally watch the show either, but my curiosity got the better of me for this episode.

  3. amamasblog Says:

    Thanks for the honest review- I didn’t watch it, but used to watch the show when it first came out. I have found a few of Jo’s techniques to work for us- the more “gentler” ones, if you will- but this episode overall sounds pretty bad.

  4. Amy Says:

    I watched this episode, since “24” has lost its appeal to me. I generally LOVE Jo and think her techniques are right on, but also didn’t agree with her on some points with this episode as well. I didn’t see the crying it out part on the show as I tuned in late and may have missed it. Not good, esp. during the time a baby is being weaned. All baby books say not to introduce more than one major change at a time, and CIO is not a method I believe in.

    Quitting breastfeeding cold turkey isn’t not a good idea either, but I do remember Jo saying several times to the mother that the ball was in her court and the decision was hers to quit or not. I was really paying attention that Jo would stress that continued BFing was FINE, and she did.

    About reaching milestones: I think Jo meant that baby could feel secure about leaving and having courage to go play in another room if the baby wanted to, or just walk around the house without being carried constantly. Being carried all the time restricts chances for a baby to explore and that’s the message I got from what Jo explained.

    So my only complaints about this episode are the CIO (which I missed) and cold-turkey quitting the BFing. I love her show and think she does a tremendous service to parents who give no structure, discipline or limits to their children.

  5. antropologa Says:

    I didn’t see the show–can’t take all the screaming in those shows–but I’m glad I read about it here. It sounds like the nanny conflated some other issues with the nursing. I don’t think nursing itself is a “relationship problem.” That’s goofy. And to wean to a bottle–how odd.

  6. Leeka Says:

    Thanks for you review- I do not watch TV at all and when heard about that episode- felt an urge to watch it- but- did not have time- so i was looking all over for a review like yours!
    It is amazing how women give up breastfeeding so early in little babe’s lives, just so to have some time for themselves or because of luck of support- I wish there were more episodes and shows about importance of prolonged breastfeeding! Just today I spoke to a girl who quit BF and “switched” to formula bc her family was pushing, saying that BF 10 MO is a non-sense! And she also never heard of La Lache League! How sad!
    I think no matter what style of parenting we choose- we must remember about balance! It is so easy to go wrong with mainestream- allowing your baby to CIO for a long periods of time, ignoring his needs of feeding and diaper changes for example and wrong with AP- not allowing your baby to CRY EVER at all- even a little- stressing over it, etc. We must learn to balance! 🙂
    Thanks again

  7. […] / made a nice post about Super? Nanny Musings of a crunchy domestic goddessSome information about it […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s